Book Your Golf Cart Rental Online & Save $5.00!

Golf Cart Rental Banner - Advertisement banner with picture of two golf carts.


Put in Bay Free Weekend - A picture of the marina with the wording "register to win a free weekend at Put in Bay."

Subscribe Today!
Sign up to become a Put-in-Bay Insider and you’ll enjoy exclusive incentives on everything from unique lodging specials to golf cart and bike rental discounts, entertainment and more. Plus, get entered for a chance at a FREE WEEKEND!

Subscribe today – it’s FREE

Upcoming Island Events

  1. Picture of Perry Peace Memorial

    Perry Peace Memorial Opens

    May 18 - October 19
  2. Picture of the Wake at the Roundhouse Bar

    The Wake

    October 19 @ 5:00 pm - October 20 @ 2:00 am
  3. Picture of Put-in-Bay Homecoming
  4. Put-in-Bay Halloween party picture

    Halloween Boo Bash at the Bay

    October 26 - October 27

Put-in-Bay Rental Homes

A wide variety of Put-in-Bay Rental Homes, Condos and Villas available for your Put-in-Bay Vacation

There are over 100 Put-in-Bay Rental Homes, Condos and Villas available for rent. These Put-in-Bay rental homes generally are ideal for larger groups. All rental homes featured below are located downtown (preferred location) and all linens, towels, sheets & pillows are provided!

Member: Put-in-Bay  8 Person Villas
440 Loraine Ave
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Picture of Put-in-Bay Rental Homes
Main: 888-742-7829

Put-in-Bay Rentals Homes


The Put-in-Bay Villas are the authority for vacation home rentals on Put-in-Bay.  Guests can expect to enjoy the comforts of home while on their Lake Erie Island adventure.  The benefits are many, including much more space, separate private bedrooms, and a full-service kitchen.  Renting a vacation home is an excellent way to stay on Put-in-Bay for both value and comfort! Put-in-Bay Villas 8 person units are located in the heart of downtown, no need for the expensive and elusive taxi to get back and forth!

Put-in-Bay Villas can accommodate to 8 guests.  Great savings on a vacation can be found by utilizing the great amenities.  The kitchen is fully equipped with all of the items needed to prepare and serve a meal.  Also, 2 large propane grills are provided for grilling up some savory selections.  After enjoying a delicious meal, step outside onto one of two outside decks to unwind.   The living areas feature comfortable furnishings, as well as a 55″ flat screen television with DirecTV service.  Four bedrooms afford guests private rooms and greater flexibility in sleeping arrangements. A heated pool with a swim up bar is located across the street along with the Blue Marlin Bar & Grill, the islands most popular swim up bar!

Unlike other home rentals on the island, you won’t need to worry about hauling your own sheets, towels, pillows & Linens along with you as it’s all provided along with daily maid service! A continental breakfast is provided daily (excluding Saturdays) Guest also enjoy a well-equipped gym on site, free parking, free hi-speed wi-fi, and golf cart rentals on site at some of the lowest rates on the island!

The Put-in-Bay Villas are an excellent choice for lodging while Visiting Put-in-Bay.  The space and flexibility that is offered is unparalleled to other options.  Be sure to consider renting a vacation home when planning an island stay.  Many wedding parties, birthday celebrations, anniversaries and more have been celebrated at the Villas.  Many dates fill fast due to high demand, so reserving early is highly recommended.

Member: Put-in-Bay 12 Person Villas
460 Loraine Ave.
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Main: 888-PIB-STAY

The 12 Person Villa features five bedrooms and three bathrooms. Four of the bedrooms have one Queen size bed and one very large bedroom has three Queen beds. The larger second-floor bathroom is equipped with a double sink bowl vanity area that is separate from the shower/bath area. Unlike most home rentals on the island, the Put-in-Bay Villas come with linens and towels! No need to worry about that you’re on vacation!
The Kitchen is equipped with a full-size refrigerator and freezer with Ice Maker, a 2 burner stove, pots, pans, dishes, granite countertops dishwasher and utensils. The living room area has a 55′ LCD TV with Direct TV programming and a deck just outside the door with a sitting area. The Second floor also has a deck overlooking the Put-in-Bay Resort pool and swim up bar.
Guest will enjoy the lushly landscaped grounds in front of each Villa with outdoor sofas and sitting areas, a waterfall, mood lighting and a splash pad for the kids. 2 large BBQ Grills are in the courtyard area and are great for family cookouts.
All Put-in-Bay Villas guests enjoy VIP access to the amities of the Put-in-Bay Resort across the street including the Blue Marlin Swim-up Bar & Grill, the 40 Person Jacuzzi, Wi-Fi and a well-equipped fitness center.
All the convenience of a home rental yet located just one block from the main strip and the vibrant Put-in-Bay nightlife.
440 Loraine Ave.
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Main:  419-285-7427

The Put-in-Bay Villas sleep 8 people per villa and are the newest and only Put-in-Bay Rental homes that are located right downtown just one block from Put-in-Bay Restaurants and nightlife. Unlike many home rentals on the island, these spacious villas are complete with linens and towels! These spacious 4 bedrooms 3 bathroom units enjoy full VIP access to the Put-in-Bay Resort & Conference Centers heated pool and swim up bar directly across the street. A full-service GYM is available to guest at no charge. Relax in the 40 Person Jacuzzi attached to the pool and swim-up bar. Guest will enjoy all the comforts of a rental home including a splash pad for the kids, waterfall and a lushly landscaped courtyard complete with two BBQ grills. An ample social area with outdoor couches, tables, and chairs is the perfect gathering spot for a family cookout or card game.

394 Loraine Ave.
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
All Star Ohio Put-in-Bay Home Rentals Photo
Main: 888-742-7829

The All-Star Ohio House is a historical and entertaining family and one of the most group friendly Put-in-Bay Rental homes located in downtown Put-in-Bay, Ohio This Put-in-Bay Rental Home is one of the most cost efficient rentals on the island for larger groups. Sleeping up to 22 people, this 6 bedroom 3 bathroom home was restored and renovated in 2016 and guests enjoy VIP access to the Put-in-Bay Resort & Conference Centers pool and swim up bar just 100 yards away. This luxurious Put-in-Bay Rental Home features a full kitchen, front and rear decks, corn hole boards, a BBQ grill all located just 50 yards from the main strip and the Put-in-Bay nightlife.