Put-in-Bay Rental Homes

A wide variety of Put-in-Bay Rental Homes and Villas available for your Put-in-Bay Vacation

There are over 20 Put-in-Bay Rental Homes, Condos, and Villas available for rent in the downtown area. Being in the downtown area means no need to depend on expensive taxis 4-5 times a weekend which gets very expensive.  These Put-in-Bay rental homes generally are ideal for larger groups and are located just a one-block walk from the nightlife, restaurants, and Put-in-Bay Attractions.

All rental homes featured below are located downtown (preferred location) and all linens, towels, sheets & pillows are provided! Be sure to check many homes force you to bring all your own towels, linens, and pillows! Who wants to mess with that? You’re on VACATION!!!!

12 Person Villa #608

440 Loraine Avenue Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, Put-in-Bay Ohio

Click To Book Now! Stay In Town! Walk To The Main Strip! No Need To Taxi!

Book Now!

12 Person Villa #609

440 Loraine Avenue Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, Put-in-Bay Ohio

Put-in-Bay Downtown Rental Homes. Heated Pool & Swim Up Bar On-Site!

Book Now!

8 Person Villa #601

440 Loraine Avenue Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, Put-in-Bay Ohio

Put-in-Bay Villas offers all the comforts of rental homes with Sheets, Towles Linens Included!

Book Now!

8 Person Villa #602

440 Loraine Avenue Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, Put-in-Bay Ohio

Your Put-in-Bay home rentals! Downtown Location with gym, pool & swim-up bar!

Book Now!

8 Person Villa #603

440 Loraine Avenue Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, Put-in-Bay Ohio

Put-in-Bay Rental Homes, all the comforts of a rental home with one of the islands BEST location.

Book Now!

8 Person Villa #604

440 Loraine Avenue Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, Put-in-Bay Ohio

Put-in-Bay Villas offers all the comforts of a rental home with a location that rivals all others —

Book Now!

8 Person Villa #605

440 Loraine Avenue Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, Put-in-Bay Ohio

Put-in-Bay Downtown Rental Homes offer all the comforts of a rental home with a location that rivals all others.

Book Now!

8 Person Villa #606

440 Loraine Avenue Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, Put-in-Bay Ohio

Put-in-Bay Home For Rent- all the comforts of a rental home with a location that rivals all others —

Book Now!

8 Person Villa #607

440 Loraine Avenue Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, Put-in-Bay Ohio

Put-in-Bay Rental Homes 4 BR 3 baths & all the comforts of home. Walk to the main strip.

Book Now!

8 Person Villa #610

440 Loraine Avenue Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, Put-in-Bay Ohio

Put-in-Bay Downtown Home Rentals with a swim-up bar & all the comforts of home! The islands best.

Book Now!

8 Person Villa #611

440 Loraine Avenue Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, Put-in-Bay, Ohio.

Put-in-Bay Villa Rental Homes – all the comforts of a rental home with a downtown location.

Book Now!

8 Person Villa #612

440 Loraine Avenue Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, Put-in-Bay Ohio

Put-in-Bay Group Home Rentals offer all the comforts of a rental home with a location that rivals all.

Book Now!

All Star Ohio House - A photo of a home rental on the Put-in-Bay, Ohio Island.

All Star Ohio House

394 Loraine Ave., Put-in-Bay Ohio

The island’s largest Put-in-Bay Rental Home- Downtown Put-in-Bay The All-Star House. Call (833) 742-2827 for booking info.

More Information
Member: Put-in-Bay 8-Person Villas
440 Loraine Ave
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Picture of Put-in-Bay Rental Homes
Main: 888-742-7829

Put-in-Bay Rentals Homes


The Put-in-Bay Villas are the authority for vacation rental homes on Put-in-Bay.  Guests can expect to enjoy the comforts of home while on their Lake Erie Island adventure.  The benefits are many, including much more space, separate private bedrooms, and a full-service kitchen.  Renting a vacation home is an excellent way to stay on Put-in-Bay for both value and comfort! Put-in-Bay Villas 8-person units are located in the heart of downtown; no need for the expensive and elusive taxi to get back and forth!

Put-in-Bay Villas can accommodate eight guests.  Great savings on vacation can be found by utilizing the great amenities.  The kitchen is fully equipped with all of the items needed to prepare and serve a meal.  Also, two large propane grills are provided for grilling up some savory selections.  After enjoying a delicious meal, step outside onto one of two outside decks to unwind.

The living areas feature comfortable furnishings, as well as a 55″ flat-screen television with DirecTV service.  Four bedrooms afford guests private rooms and greater flexibility in sleeping arrangements. A heated pool with a swim-up bar is located across the street along with the Blue Marlin Bar & Grill, the island’s most popular swim-up bar!

Unlike other home rentals on the island, you won’t need to worry about hauling your own sheets, towels, pillows & Linens along with you as it’s all provided along with daily maid service! A continental breakfast is provided daily (excluding Saturdays). Guests also enjoy a well-equipped gym on-site, free parking, free high-speed wi-fi, and golf cart rentals on-site at some of the lowest rates on the island!

The Put-in-Bay Villas are an excellent choice for lodging while visiting Put-in-Bay.  The space and flexibility that are offered are unparalleled to other options.  Be sure to consider renting a vacation home when planning an island stay.  Many wedding parties, birthday celebrations, anniversaries, and more have been celebrated at the Villas.  Many dates fill fast due to high demand, so reserving early is highly recommended.

Member: Put-in-Bay 12 Person Villas
460 Loraine Ave.
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Main: 888-PIB-STAY


The 12 Person Villa home rentals feature five bedrooms and three bathrooms. Four of the bedrooms have one Queen size bed and one very large bedroom has three Queen beds. The larger second-floor bathroom is equipped with a double sink bowl vanity area that is separate from the shower/bath area. Unlike most home rentals on the island, the Put-in-Bay Villas come with linens and towels! No need to worry about that you’re on vacation!
The Kitchen is equipped with a full-size refrigerator and Freezer with Ice Maker, a 2 burner stove, pots, pans, dishes, granite countertops dishwasher, and utensils. The living room area has a 55′ LCD TV with Direct TV programming and a deck just outside the door with a sitting area. The second floor also has a deck overlooking the Put-in-Bay Resort pool and swim-up bar.
Guest will enjoy the lushly landscaped grounds in front of each Villa with outdoor sofas and sitting areas, a waterfall, mood lighting, and a splash pad for the kids. 2 large BBQ Grills are in the courtyard area and are great for family cookouts.
All Put-in-Bay Villa Rental Homes guests enjoy VIP access to the amities of the Put-in-Bay Resort across the street including the Blue Marlin Swim-up Bar & Grill, the 40 Person Jacuzzi, Wi-Fi, and a well-equipped fitness center.
All the convenience of a home rental yet located just one block from the main strip and the vibrant Put-in-Bay nightlife.
440 Loraine Ave.
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Main:  419-285-7427
Website:  www.putinbayvillas.com

The Put-in-Bay Villas sleep 8 people per villa and are the newest and only Put-in-Bay Rental homes that are located right downtown just one block from Put-in-Bay Restaurants and nightlife. Unlike many home rentals on the island, these spacious villas are complete with linens and towels!

These spacious 4 bedrooms 3 bathroom units enjoy full VIP access to the Put-in-Bay Resort & Conference Centers heated pool and the swim-up bar directly across the street. A full-service GYM is available to guests at no charge.

Relax in the 40 Person Jacuzzi attached to the pool and swim-up bar. Guest will enjoy all the comforts of a rental home including a splash pad for the kids, waterfall, and a lushly landscaped courtyard complete with two BBQ grills. An ample social area with outdoor couches, tables, and chairs is the perfect gathering spot for a family cookout or card game.

394 Loraine Ave.
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
All Star Ohio Put-in-Bay Home Rentals Photo
Main: 833-742-2827
Website: www.allstarohiohouseputinbay.com

The All-Star Ohio House is a historical and entertaining family and one of the most group-friendly Put-in-Bay Rental homes located in downtown Put-in-Bay, Ohio. This Put-in-Bay Rental Home is one of the most cost-efficient rentals on the island for larger groups. Sleeping up to 22 people, this six bedrooms 3 bathroom home was restored and renovated in 2016, and guests enjoy VIP access to the Put-in-Bay Resort & Conference Center’s pool and swim-up bar just 100 yards away. This luxurious Put-in-Bay Rental Home features a full kitchen, front and rear decks, corn hole boards, and a BBQ grill all located just 50 yards from the main strip and the Put-in-Bay nightlife.

Put-in-Bay Lodging Resort and Rental Homes Options

When most people are planning a vacation or a trip out of town, they think of hotels. A weekend or family getaway trip to Lake Erie’s South Bass Island island may work better with a larger alternative option! In the past, the typical Put-in-Bay Hotel or Resort could only provide rooms or suites. If you wanted to stay in a rental home or cabin a few years ago you were relegated to staying in prefab older Island Club Homes way out in the center of the island, This required taking a taxi in and out of town which was quite expensive. The solution? See Below!

The Put-in-Bay Villa Home Rentals

A few years ago the Put-in-Bay Resort the island’s largest and newest hotel acquired land across from the resort and opened the new Put-in-ay Villas. Ultra-modern 4 & 5 bedroom rental homes all with three bathrooms, kitchens, two decks, and a stunningly landscaped courtyard with waterfall. These comfortable modern Put-in-Bay Rental Homes enjoy all of the amenities of the Put-in-Bay Resort such as a heated pool & swim-up bar, exercise facility, The Blue Marlin Bar & Grill, and best of all just one block off the main strip!

With these larger rental homes, you can keep your group together and not have to worry about finding a taxi or the added expense. Focus your time on having fun and enjoying outings to the famous nearby Put-in-Bay sites like The Caves, The Fish Hatchery, and  Perry’s Cave, and Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial

Enjoy The Best Ohio Getaway

Put-in-Bay is such a difference from most of Ohio, you’d be forgiven for believing you were actually in the Florida Keys! Put-in-Bay downtown is home to more restaurants and bars than you can enjoy in just one night!, Even though it’s just an hour from Cleveland, and less from Toledo, and just a boat ride away from Sandusky Ohio, and Cedar Point, it’s as if you’re in another place Pretty much everything is within walking distance in the vibrant downtown area, and a Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Rental will get you anywhere else you need to go at Put-in-Bay.

Put-in-Bay Cabins, Condos, And More

Selecting the right Put-in-Bay Rental Homes home is an important step in planning a memorable trip. Would you choose the Island Club and have to stay out in the middle of the island? Most would not! Put-in-Bay villa vacation rentals with their downtown location have become the obvious choice for Put-in-Bay Home Rentals!

These spacious and private Put-in-Bay Rental Homes include amenities such as kitchens that are fully-equipped kitchens, Parking, propane grills, and private outdoor gathering areas. The kitchens are a great way to save a little money and make family meals in your home to avoid eating out every night. Or, what the heck you’re on vacation enjoy the Put-in-Bay Restaurants!

A Midweek Put-in-Bay Villa Rental Homes stay will also benefit from special discounted add-ons such as Put-in-Bay golf cart rentals and midweek lower rates! Invite your family members and friends, there is plenty of room and you can request your rental homes to be next to each other!

With other sought-after amenities like free wifi, easy check-in, and the best locations on the island there’s no doubt that you’ll have an excellent experience at your Put-in-Bay, Ohio, rental home. It’s your home away from home, but on an island!

Not Just Another Put-in-Bay Resort

All Put-in-Bay Villa Rental Homes include daily service, linens, and towels (something you WON”T Find at an Island Club Cabin. Put-In-Bay offers a wide selection of great Vacation Rental Properties.  This website is an excellent source to research, compare and reserve your home. There is something to match everyone and anyone’s lodging needs. The sooner you book, the sooner you can get here!

Put-in-Bay Ohio, The northern Most Island Paradise In The USA

Put-in-Bay is one of the most well-known vacation destinations in the northern half of the United States. A short ferry ride from Port Clinton will bring you face to face with an island paradise, with famous nightlife, tiki bars, and more. The Put-in-Bay island life will take you so far away from your 9 to 5, you may never want to go back. Explore this website for information on upcoming events and more to find the best time to come see us at the Bay!

Other Put-In-Bay Lodging Choices

VRBO and Airbnb have become more popular over the years but generally results in paying a higher price than booking directly with the property. Read our helpful article about how to get your best rates on hotels and Put-in-Bay Rental Home here:

The Put-in-Bay Villas are some of the most sought after lodging on Put-in-Bay. These beautiful new units are located across from the Put-in-Bay Resort and Conference Center. The Villas cater to groups of all sizes with luxury amenities coupled with the conveniences of home. The Villas regularly sell out every weekend during the summer season, so reserve your unit very early on in the year.

These three-story villas can sleep groups of 8 to 12 comfortably. The well-appointed interiors include a kitchenette with microwave, refrigerator, freezer microwave, and wet-bar. The spacious living room area has a fabulous 55” flat-screen TV with free DIRECT TV service. Queen size beds can be found in each of the four bedrooms along with three bathrooms.

Luxury linens are provided. Two private patios can be found off of the first and second floors. Enjoy summer evenings with family and friends cooking out and enjoying the warm summer breezes with a glass of wine.

The Put-in-Bay Villa Rental Homes also features exceptional service for guests in this gated and secure community. 24-hour security is available on the weekends. The Villas include daily housekeeping. Guests enjoy all amenities of the nearby Put-in-Bay Resort across the street. This includes the award-winning Blue Marlin Tiki Bar & Grill located right next to the pool and the largest jacuzzi in the world.

This hot tub can fit up to 40 people. This spot is always lively and fun. Blue Marlin specialty cocktails pair perfectly with a dip in the crystal clear pool. The Put-in-Bay Pizza Company delivers poolside and serves the island’s most popular pizza, grinders, and wings! this restaurant always satisfies.

A fully equipped conference center is also located at Put-in-Bay Resort if you are planning a wedding or business retreat. There are several different size rooms and ballrooms available, on-site wedding planners, and different catering menus. Moped, golf carts, and bicycle rentals are also offered at the resort. The preferred way to get around Put-in-Bay, the golf carts often sell out so reserve yours today!

The All-Star Ohio House – Put-in-Bay’s Most sought after Home Retnals

The All-Star Ohio House is one of Put-in-Bay newest premier Put-in-Bay Rental Homes. This Victorian beauty was totally gutted and remodeled in 2015 to celebrate all things sporting and Ohio State. Buckeye Scarlett & Gray are the predominant colors! The Rental Home is located right in the heart of downtown Put-in-Bay.

The spacious house is minutes from the Jet Express terminal and pretty much close to everything! The house can sleep up to 22 guests. The main feature of the house is the large master suite with a sitting area and private bath, which features a luxurious oversized bathtub.

Four bedrooms along with three full baths complete the layout. Each room is decorated in Buckeye Scarlett & Gray with red leather couches in the roomy living room. A 60” TV is the perfect place to catch your favorite sports event. There is free Wifi throughout the house. The beds are outfitted with high-quality linens.

Towels and toiletries are also included in your stay. The large full kitchen makes it easy to whip up delicious drinks and appetizers and throw BBQs with all your friends. Golf Cart Discounts are also available. This is the best way to traverse Put-in-Bay.

Outdoor space is plentiful at The All-Star Ohio House. The front porch and courtyard are a great place to people watch Put-in-Bay bustle by. Guests can even see Lake Erie from here. The back patio is very large with picnic tables with umbrellas, a propane grill, even a corn hole board set!

A great spot to host get-togethers with friends or have a few cocktails before heading out onto the town. Put-in-Bay is a great place to bring groups of friends. Whether it’s a boy’s weekend, a Bachelor party, or a family reunion, this island provides never-ending fun activities along with world-class dining and Put-in-Bay Entertainment.