Book Your Golf Cart Rental Online & Save!
Put-in-Bay Restaurants
There are many choices when it comes to Put-in-Bay Restaurants from sports oriented to fine dining. Browse the island’s restaurants below and tell us what’s your favorite!
| Member: | Blue Marlin Grill (Located poolside at the Put-in-Bay Resort) 439 Loraine Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-7427 |
| Website: | Blue Marlin Bar & Grill at the Put-in-Bay Resort |
| Description: | The Blue Marlin Bar & Grill restaurant is located poolside at the Put-in-Bay Resort, the islands most popular resort hotel. The Blue Marlin offers a wide variety of sandwiches, oven-baked grinders, salads, pizzas and basket dinners. You can dine poolside or enjoy a seat at the Bar with their 60″ TV’S showing popular sporting events. One of the only restaurants that you can take the kids for a dip in the pool and a relaxing lunch or dinner. |
| Member: | SUBWAY 272 Delaware Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-5555 |
| Website: | Subway Put-in-Bay |
| Description: | Located in the lobby of the Commodore Hotel in downtown Put-in-Bay, the Subway offers traditional subs on freshly baked breads. Subway is a perfect picnic option for nearby DeRivera Park or the Put-in-Bay State Park Subway is open late night as well! |
| Member: | PUT-IN-BAY PIZZA COMPANY 439 Loraine Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-0504 |
| Website: | Put-in-Bay Pizza Company |
| Description: | The Put-in-Bay Pizza Company is located in the Put-in-Bay Resort and caters to the entire island. They offer free delivery and are an island favorite for that late night Pizza Craving. They are well known for their oven-baked Grinder Sandwiches and offer a wide selection of appetizers and munchies for delivery. |
| Member: | THE BOARDWALK 2 Bayview Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-3695 |
| Website: | The Boardwalk Restaurant |
| Description | The Boardwalk Family of Restaurants is a waterfront development that is home to several of Put-in-Bay’s best restaurants you will read about here. The lower level has a cafeteria style service line offering the freshest seafood including Alaskan King Crab, Live Maine Lobster, Key West Shrimp, and New Zealand Mussels with a large selection of deli-style sandwiches, wraps and of course their FAMOUS LOBSTER BISQUE!!!! |
| Member: | CHICKEN PATIO Delaware Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-4595 |
| Website: | Chicken Patio Put-in-Bay |
| Description: | The Chicken Patio serves a grilled wine basted Chicken Dinner Complete with corn on the cob, rolls, and potato salad outdoors with a view of DeRivera park and the Put-in-Bay Waterfront. Since 1952, the Chicken Patio has been a destination spot for BBQ and their homemade wine based BBQ sauce. Orders are also available for carryout. |
| Member: | FROSTY’S FAMILY PIZZA AND BAR 252 Delaware Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-3278 |
| Website: | Frosty Family Pizza |
| Description: | The Frosty Family Pizza restaurant has been an island tradition for over 60 years continuously being operated by the Stoiber family. Serving their well-known pizza and subs, they are also a popular place for breakfast on the island. Many people do not consider a visit to Put-in-Bay complete without a Frosty Pizza. |
| Member: | THE GOAT SOUP AND WHISKEY 820 Catawba Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-GOAT |
| Website: | The Goat Soup and Whisky |
| Description: | The Goat Soup and Whisky is housed in a historical building near the center of the island. The menu features one of Put-in-Bay’s widest variety including steaks, Lake Erie Perch and Walleye, pastas, salads, their Famous Perch Taco’s and their signature homemade soups and sauces. |
| Member: | MOSSBACKS ISLAND BAR AND GRILLE 371 Catawba Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-8888 |
| Website: | Mossbacks Restaurant |
| Description: | Mossbacks Restaurant is located right downtown Put-in-Bay and offers diners a view of the Put-in-Bay Waterfront and DeRivera Park. Mossbacks serves Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner. Known for their Lake Erie Perch, their extensive menu also offers a wide selection of appetizers, Soups and Salads, Steaks & Burgers, Signature Sandwiches, and a Mossbacks Favorite Pierogies. A full liquor bar with craft beers and wine is available. |
| Member: | HOOLIGANS TAVERN 421 Catawba Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-5450 |
| Website: | Hooligans Irish Pub |
| Description: | At Hooligan’s, friendly well-trained staff combined with a heaping plate of Irish hospitality and authentic Irish Grub makes this Put-in-Bay Restaurant a must visit. Operating under the fundamentals of a true public house with an exciting menu and bar. Combine the pleasure of a refreshing pint along with Meatloaf, Shepard’s Pie, Fish & Chips, a wide selection of sandwiches and burgers and a complete children’s menu. |
| Member: | PRESS HOUSE JOE’S BAR Red Barn, Catawba Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-5637 |
| Website: | Press House Joe’s |
| Description: | Looking for a little “Local Color” Press House Joe’s is where you will find it! Known for their Sloppy “Joe’s” and killer hot dogs Press House Joe’s offers inside and outside dining and is located neat the Put-in-Bay Ohio State Park. With a motto “Beer is Food” How can you go wrong? |
| Member: | BIG MAN’S BURRITO STAND 252 Delaware Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-3278 |
| Website: | Big Mans Burrito Stand |
| Description: | When your thinking Tex Mex Big man’s burrito stand located behind the Frosty Family Pizza is one of two options on the island for Tex Mex with large stuffed burritos, tacos and salads. The Backyard Bar is a fun outdoor venue that serves fresh fruit margaritas, specialty cocktails and offers night time entertainment. |
| Member: | THE BOATHOUSE BAR AND GRILL 218 Hartford Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-5665 |
| Website: | Boathouse Bar & Grill |
| Description: | The Boathouse Bar & Grill is located in downtown Put-in-Bay near the waterfront and DeRivera Park. In operation for over 50 years, the Boathouse Restaurant offers locally sourced Lake Erie Perch and Walleye along with southern style food including burgers, Po Boys and Seafood Baskets. They offer inside and outside patio dining, a full-service bar, and entertainment. For additional information on bands and entertainers visit the Put-in-Bay Entertainment page. |
| Member: | DAIRY ISLE Bayview Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-3506 |
| Website: | Dairy Isle |
| Description: | Located in downtown Put-in-Bay near the Perry’s Peace Memorial the Dairy isle offers all Char Broiled Burgers, Onion Rings, Chicken Strips, Perch Sandwiches and salads and wraps. Milkshakes, Sundaes, Ice Cream Cones and Storm Flurry’s make this a family favorite. |
| Member: | MAMA MARIA’S 266 Delaware Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-7400 |
| Website: | None |
| Description: | Located in the front of the Edgewater Hotel on the main strip downtown Put-in-Bay. One of Put-in-Bays Casual Restaurants, they are known for their pizzas, meatball sandwiches, subs and are a must have for late night food service. |
| Member: | PASQUALE’S 234 Delaware Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-8600 |
| Website: | Pasquale’s Cafe |
| Description: | Pasquale’s Cafe features Italian and American favorites with a nice view of the downtown waterfront. Open for breakfast, Lunch & Dinner,the restaurants best know for hearty breakfasts and a great family oriented atmosphere. |
| Member: | PUT-IN-BAY BREWING COMPANY 441 Catawba Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-HOPS |
| Website: | www.putinbaybrewery.com |
| Description: | Of all restaurants at Put-in-Bay, only one can boast being Put-in-Bay’s only brewery and now a distillery too!. Located inside a historical building that throughout history has served as a grocery, a garage, and a fire station. Since the spring of 1996, the Put-in-Bay Brewery has added a comprehensive menu that includes such specialties as Lake Erie Perch, Steaks, Homemade Soups and sandwiches and of course the well known Brewery Pizza. An ample kids menu is available. |
| Member: | VILLAGE BAKERY 104 Delaware Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-5351 |
| Website: | Village Bakery and Cafe |
| Description: | Another place of local color is loaded with local flavor! The Village Bakery is where you will find many islanders enjoying a cup of freshly brewed coffee along with one of Pauline’s freshly baked goods! We can’t say enough about her danish, pastries and cupcakes! The bakery also serves salads, breakfast and lunch sandwiches and creates custom cakes for special occasions and Put-in-Bay Weddings by special order. |
| Member: | THE FISH SHACK 2 Bayview Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-3695 |
| Internet: | www.the-boardwalk.com |
| Description: | Located on the left in the main entrance to the Boardwalk dining complex is the Fish Shack serving Lake Erie Perch, Walleye, battered shrimp with some great sides and hand breaded jumbo onion rings. |
| Member: | LITTLE GALLEY 2 Bayview Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-3695 |
| Website: | www.the-boardwalk.com |
| Description: | For Certified Angus Beef Burgers, 1/4 lb all beef hot dogs, chicken strip and fries all served with a magnificent view of the Put-in-Bay Docks the Little Galley hits the spot. Located inside the Boardwalk Restaurant Complex, they offer seating inside and outside. |
| Member: | Margarita’s On The Rock 180 Toledo Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-3040 |
| Website: | Margaritas On The Rock |
| Description: | Margaritas on the Rock boasts a wide variety of hand-crafted and thoughtfully designed margaritas, cocktails and frozen drinks. Using fresh ingredients and an expansive tequila selection, there’s a drink for everyone on the Rock! Stop by any weekend this August to experience our live entertainment showcasing a band straight from St. Thomas, VI!Come to feel the island breeze and listen to some authentic reggae tunes as you sip your margaritas and enjoy our southwestern menu! |
| Member: | BOOK’S SEAFOOD 2 Bayview Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-3695 |
| Website: | www.the-boardwalk.com |
| Description: | Another great offering at The Boardwalk Restaurants location, Book’s Seafood boasts a variety of delicious entrees including King crab, lobster, shrimp, and mussels are just a few of the fine seafood fare you’ll find here. As with all of the Boardwalk Restaurants, some of the best dining views on the island can be found here. |
| Member: | UPPER DECK 2 Bayview Ave Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-3695 |
| Website: | www.the-boardwalk.com |
| Description: | Upper Deck Restaurant patrons will enjoy a panoramic view of the downtown harbor in an upscale dining experience. Located on the second level of The Boardwalk Restaurant next to the Put-in-Bay public docks, the fresh seafood, and steak options will surely please your palate. Come and catch a great view and meal. |
| Member: | DOCKSIDE 2190 Langram Rd Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-2627 |
| Internet: | www.yelp.com/biz/island-scoops-put-in-bay |
| Description: | At the Lime Kiln Dock of the Miller Ferry is a great spot to cool off. Ice cream offerings include milkshakes and cones, and they will surely help you beat the heat on those hot summer days. Also, Dockside offers hotdogs and pizza by the slice from Cameo Pizza of Putinbay. So, whether you are coming or going, they are ready to serve you at the Lime Kiln. |
| Member: | THE FISH BOWL Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-8888 |
| Website: | The Fish Bowl |
| Description: | The Fishbowl is located in the same complex as Mossbacks Restaurants and offers a laid back relaxed atmosphere for lunch or dinner. Freshly made soups, large sandwiches, wings, and robust salads with a full-service bar and late-night food menu. |
| Member: | The Old Forge Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-0022 |
| Website: | The Old Forge |
| Description: | The Old Forge is located in the original Blacksmiths building in downtown Put-in-Bay. Serving their famous crepes, they also are a great spot for breakfast, lunch and dinner. An outside patio bar is a great place to enjoy an espresso and people watch. |
| Member: | THE KEYS RESTAURANTS Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-5397 |
| Website: | The Keys Restaurants |
| Description: | The Keys Restaurants are located on the waterfront in downtown next to the Put-in-Bay Ferry Boat Landing. Within the restaurants complex there are 4 separate restaurants each offering Florida theme dining with such mouthwatering dishes as Conch Chowder, Key West Shrimp, Fresh Florida Grouper and BBQ Ribs. Many of the restaurants in the complex offer water view or waterfront dining and all offer full bar service. |
| Member: | THE REEL BAR Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-1318 |
| Website: | The Reel Bar |
| Description: | For Many years Islanders frequented a establishment call “Tony’s Place” which was built in 1906. In 2014 it was transformed into the Reel Bar but still to this day pays homage to its Put-in-Bay History with its decor and Great Lake Theme. With over 30 fine Bourbons on the shelf and 16 different draft beers, you will have no problem finding that perfect cocktail to enjoy with their fine menu selection. Serving Breakfast, Lunch and Dinner, The Reel Bar features Hand Held Tacos, Short Rib Philly, Steaks, Perch and Grouper among other fresh salads and sandwiches. |
| Member: | TOPSY TURVEY’S GRILL Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 |
| Main: | 419-285-4511 |
| Website: | Topsy Turveys Grill |
| Description: | Located inside of the Wharfside building the Topsy Turvey Grill is known for their Cuban sandwiches and small but fun observation and dining deck overlooking the Put-in-Bay Harbor. |
Let’s Get Social