Put-in-Bay Pizza Company

Put-in-Bay Pizza Company is the islands go to for Pizza Delivery at Put-in-Bay. Voted the best pizza on the island for consecutive years. Put-in-Bay Pizza Company offers delivery to all Put-in-Bay Hotels and rental homes as well as local business establishments. Their fresh ingredients and inhouse made pizza sauce blend together to make the perfect pie.

Completing the menu are a host of Grinder Sandwiches served on a freshly baked sub roll and cooked in a stone oven. Put-in-Bay Pizza Company offers late-night delivery and is capable of catering events up to 400 people.

Put-in-Bay Pizza Delivery - Photo of the Put-in-Bay Pizza Company

Put-in-Bay Pizza Company Delivery Details

For the last 10 years, the Put-in-Bay Pizza Company quietly operated from the Put-in-Bay Resort Hotels Blue Marlin Bar And Grill. Their popularity swelled and soon they outgrew their location and moved to the center of downtown Put-in-Bay. They offer pizza delivery to all locations on the island and are available to cater to large groups and outings.

Put-in-Bay Pizza Delivery is available until  3 AM on weekends and 1 am on a seasonal basis. They have teamed up with Lesters Taco Shop where you can also order the islands best Latin Inspired Food for delivery!

If Pizza is not in the plans, their homemade Grinder oven-baked subs are sure to hit the spot, or for lighter fare, a good selection of fresh salads is available.

Put-in-Bay Pizza Company Menu Highlights

  • Chicken Alfredo Pizza
  • Meatlovers Pizza
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
  • Wing Ding Brand Spicy Chicken Wings
  • Fajita Chicken Salad
  • Baked Italian Grinder
  • Fajita Chicken Grinder

Quality Food A Fair Price – Put-in-Bay Pizza Company

Np matter where you are staying at Put-in-Bay, The Put-in-Bay Pizza Company is just a short golf cart ride away or let them deliver hot and fast to your door. Their prices are among the lowest on the island while their quality is uncompromised.

Serving Lunch, Dinner & Late Night Food, they are one of the most affordable Put-in-Bay Restaurants and one of the best-kept secrets for a quick inexpensive meal. Have one delivered poolside for that casual afternoon lunch!

Put-in-Bay Pizza delivers islandwide for a small fee (minimum order may apply) and to all local Put-in-Bay Hotels. They also cater to large groups. conferences or special events. After a long night enjoying the Put-in-Bay Entertainment, nothing quite hits the spot like a slice of Pepperoni Pizza!

  • Put-in-Bay Pizza Company

  • Address: 264 Delaware Ave, Put-In-Bay, OH 43456

  • View Our Menu

WOW! Great pizza and our order was delivered very fast for as busy as the island was. Lots of Pepperoni and cooked perfectly!

Todd Smith

Ordered for our meeting of 50 people. Delivered right on time! Highly recommend! Good choice of menu options.

Mark WIlson

This place has become the new ‘must-try” hangout later night on the island. LOVE THIS PIZZA!

LIsa Rowels

The best white pizza I have ever had! This chicken alfredo pizza was ready for pick up 20 min after ordering, The pizza crust was light and crisp. The chicken was perfectly cooked breast meat cut into medium size cubes. The broccoli was finely chopped and evenly distributed all over the pizza. And the white sauce was delish. My wife and I ate ours up, and our kids loved it too. The Put-in-Bay Pizza Company has nowhere to eat in, but this is a great place for pickup or to have delivered if you’re staying at Put-in-Bay.

Lenny Burns

Put-in-Bay Pizza Company is a 5-minute walk from most of the Put-in-Bay Hotels. We stopped in for cheese bread and a pepperoni pizza. The place was packed (Friday night) but the service was good! We didn’t have anything else to do so it was worth it! The pizza crust and sauce are very unique – absolutely love it! The thin crust was perfect (not as thin as Pizza Hut ) And the sauce is great.

Miles Counrtney

Awesome pizza. This is a hidden gem at Put-in-Bay. Some of the best pizza we’ve ever had. My daughter wanted to come back to Put-in-Bay just so we could eat this pizza all the time. Next time we are visiting South Bass Island we will be back to eat Put-in-Bay pizza!!

Lisa Cosby