Frosty Bar Family Pizza

For over 60 years, the Frosty Bar Family Pizza has been a Put-in-Bay institution and is owned by the Stoiber family. There are a number of bars located on Put-in-Bay, but Frosty’s signature frosty mugs make them best known for serving ice-cold beers. Boaters, day-trippers, holidaymakers, and residents of the island all call Frosty’s Pizza a favorite.

Frosty Bar Family Pizza - Store front view of Frostys Bar and Frosty Pizza next door.

With a Put-in-Bay twist, Frosty Bar Family Pizza a classic dive bar. It is the perfect place to celebrate summer on Put-in-Bay with extra delicious food served up alongside live music, pool tables, and the game on TV. In the evenings, the masses are entertained by a DJ or pair! To see who’s playing, be sure to review the Put-in-Bay Entertainment Schedule!

At the rear of the bar, Big Man’s Burrito Stand is stationed and serves the best Mexican food on the island. With a serious side of taste, Frosty’s serves up traditional American fare.

Frostys Bar Family Pizza Menu Highlights

For breakfast try:

Country Benedict
Sausage Gravy and Biscuits
Mexican Sunrise
Eggs Benedict

Frostys Bar Family Pizza Lunch & Dinner Menu

  • Frosty’s Family Meal
  • Italian Sub
  • Veggie Wrap
  • Chicken Cobb Salad
  • Tossed Salad

On the island, their iconic breakfast menu at Frostys Bar Family Pizza is always a success. Sometimes there is a short wait, but you can drink coffee or one of their brunch cocktails while you wait. Their heaping breakfast sandwiches, tasty blueberry pancakes, and the famed Eggs Benedict are many favorites.

Some of the best Bloody Mary’s can be found at Frosty Pizza, topped off with a signature Frosty pickle. They make a wide variety of innovative cocktails for all hours of the day.

Frostys Bar Family Pizza Speciality Cocktail Offerings

Frosty Mug Cocktails:

  • Bottled or Canned Beer
  • Draft Beer
  • Irish Iced Coffee
  • Cuban OJ
  • Frosty O
  • Formosa
  • Bloody Mary
  • Classic Margarita
  • Bottled Domestic or Canned Beers
  • Ice Cold Draft Beers

Ideally located close to most Put-in-Bay Hotels,  Frosty Bar Family Pizza is an excellent first or last spot on the island. Swing by for a bite or drink before visiting one of the many Put-in-Bay attractions on the island.

Why not enjoy a little shopping after a hearty meal at Frosty Family Pizza Bar? Many nearby gift shops are here, only steps away! To name a few the Country House, Lovella Fashion Clothing, Put-in-Bay Surf Store, and the Carriage House are all located right on the Delaware Avenue strip! The head to the famous Blue Marlin Pool Bar at the Put-in-Bay Resort for an afternoon of fun!

Like This Restaurant? Share It With A Friend!

  • Frosty Bar Family Pizza

  • Address: 252 Delaware Avenue Put-in-Bay Ohio 43456

  • View Our Menu

Frosty Bar Family Pizza is one place we always have to stop at when we’re in Put-in-Bay! The backyard bar is awesome and all of the bartenders out there are very friendly. The pizza here is wonderful as well, and the breakfast is the best! Super fun place with a nice atmosphere and great staff. Definitely stop here for a beer in a frosty mug!

David Whitman

I can see Frosty Bar Family Pizza could probably get rowdy and crowded late at night but my wife and I went earlier in the day. Only a few drunk people in there and a few older men.

Slower service but beer glasses were ice cold. Miller’s light watered down taste and the nachos were great. But fairly cheap and cool inside, a lot of decors to look at and t-shirts. Clean inside too.

Mark Miller

We needed a dog-friendly place to eat lunch during our day trip memorial day weekend! The staff was awesome. Our dog even got her own dog bowl with iced water! We enjoyed the garlic breadstick, they were nothing like we have tasted before.

We also enjoyed a pepperoni and cheese wood-fired pizza! It was so good. The pepperoni was huge and under the cheese. They do not go easy on the cheese either which is great. Who likes a pizza that has hardly any cheese.

The sauce was good and not too heavy. We will definitely be back to Frosty Bar Family Pizza next time we are on the island.

LIsa Lewis

Put-in-Bay has few notable places for a good breakfast but what sets Frosty Bar Family Pizza apart are the potatoes. Fresh shredded and delicious, not deep-fried cubes or tootsie roll nubs. Get the biscuits and gravy with a side of the potatoes and you’ll be loving life

Jeff Shope, Your Content Goes Here

My grandson and I were greeted at Frosty Bar Family Pizza by Jurgis with a frosty cold pitcher of water and 2 cups the moment we sat down. It was HELL outside and we were exhausted from the heat. We ordered the Brie and chicken pizza with sundried tomatoes to nibble on while we cooled down and rested. Fabulous!!! We also ordered frozen drinks, one smoothie, and one very boozy drink for me, which were good.

This restaurant/bar was SPOTLESS! Gorgeous hardwood floors and calm colors on the walls. And the service very attentive. Jurgis even brought us a kid’s fun paper so my grandson and I could play tic tac toe while cooking off. We didn’t plan to come here, we were hot and exhausted and this was the place before us. I recommend families to come here. We’ll be back.

Trecy Hughes, Your Content Goes Here

Always visit Frosty Bar Family Pizza several times while on the island. A great party in the bar-room; seating in the restaurant area. It’s always cool inside too when you are trying to get away from the heat it is one of the better hideouts on the island.

Liv Oneil, Your Content Goes Here

We were going to have breakfast at another restaurant down the street. They had a waiting line so we decided to try FrostyBar Family Pizza. So glad we did. The service by our youthful Lithuanian server was great. We each had the Quick and Easy. 2 eggs (we did scrambled), bacon, hash browns, and toast. There were 4 slices of bacon!

We recommended this restaurant to people waiting to get into the OTHER restaurant when we left. Some left the line and went to Frostys.

Frank Piersol, Your Content Goes Here