Pasquale’s Cafe

When it’s time to Breakfast well, line up for some of Put-in-Bay’s best Breakfast at Pasquale’s Cafe. For over 20 years, this trendy, family-owned spot has served the masses and is a locals’ favorite morning-time gathering place. Featuring made from scratch favorites, the line out the door tells you it is definitely worth the wait!

Photo of Pasquale's Cafe One of the Put-in-Bay Restaurants

Pasquale’s Cafe Particulars

Located just across the street from historic DeRivera Park on Delaware Avenue, Pasquale’s Cafe is simple to find and even easier to enjoy. Look for Frosty Family Pizza And Bar and T&J’s Smokehouse, and the Cafe sits right between the two! Ample Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Rental parking is permitted during daytime hours right on the main street!

The bright modern interior is usually jammed packed, serving Breakfast & lunch. While Pasquales’s Cafe is almost always full, the vibe is informal and relaxed. The backdrop is never too loud to converse with family and friends, and the soft white noise reminds you of the neighborhood dine from long ago. Breakfast is one of the main reasons to visit Pasquale’s Cafe, but the entire menu is ample and unique. The TripAdvisor Certificate of Excellence in both 2017 and 2016 recognizes their attention to detail.

Opening bright and early at 7 am. the early birds get the best seating. No worries, Breakfast is served all day for you late sleepers, and the lunch/dinner menu is available starting at 12 pm. Pasquale’s Cafe is open daily from June – August, with limited hours in April, May, September, and October. Carryout is available by phone or walk-in ordering.

Pasquale’s Cafe – The Famous Breakfast Menu

The best way to play at Put-in-Bay is to start your day off right with Breakfast at Pasquale’s Cafe. An enticing menu full of incredible fluffy omelets, pancakes, and egg benedicts ensures nobody goes hungry here. Choose from a dazzling array of homemade waffles, handmade fresh omelets, and favorites like the breakfast pizza. A children’s menu is available for the kids!

Featured Breakfast Highlights

• Classic Buttermilk Hotcakes with Strawberries and Cream
• Lobster Benedict
• Sausage Breakfast and Gravy
• Breakfast Quesadilla
• Ham and Cheese Omelets

The local’s house favorite is called The Hot Mess. Loaded with Scrambled eggs, hash browns, cherry wood smoked bacon, and cheddar Monterey jack cheese is combined for a plate piled high with flavor! Toast is served on the side. No meal is complete without a piping hot cup of freshly brewed coffee, hot chocolate, or fresh juice.

Pasquale’s Cafe Lunch and Dinner

The lunch and dinner offerings are just as impressive at Pasquale’s Cafe. Breakfast is served all day, of course, if you find yourself craving Breakfast. Beer and wine is available to complement your meal with an extensive list to select from.

Lunch and Dinner Menu Favorites

• Roast Cauliflower and Quinoa Burger
• Lake Erie Yellow Perch Sandwich
• Lobster Spinach Dip
• Benedict Burgers
• BBQ Brisket Mac’ n Cheese
• Philly Steak and Cheese
• Sirloin Steak

Pasquale’s Cafe makes classic American food specialties with enough variety to satisfy everyone! Enticing Appetizers always start the meal off right. A favorite is Pepperoni Bread stuffed with Italian Cheese and Pepperoni with a side of marinara. Twisted Calamari is a spicy take of this Carribien island favorite and is served with chipotle ranch dipping sauce.

Their hearty sandwiches are served with your choice of beer-battered fries or house-made coleslaw. The burgers all start with two premium Black Angus patties and are served up on a fresh brioche bun with fries.

Pizzas baked to order include the classic White Pizza, Margherita to Chicken Bacon Ranch, and the Bianca. Enjoy one of their signature pies or create your own.

If salad is more your style, you also have many options from the classic Caesar to the delicious Summer Salad served with fresh strawberries and mandarin oranges! Add some grilled chicken or breaded perch to any salad!

Like This Restaurant? Share It With A Friend!

  • Pasquale’s Cafe

  • Address: 240 Delaware Ave, Put-In-Bay, OH 43456

  • Website: Pasquale’s Cafe 

  • View Our Menu

Arrived on the Jet Express and walked directly to Pasquale’s Cafe. Had a brief 10-minute wait for a party of 4..we got lucky as it is a popular place! The hard-working and friendly staff was very accommodating even with keeping the new Covid 19 procedures in place. Excellent coffee! Lobster Benedict, breakfast burritos, and the Hot Mess breakfast bowl! Yum.

Jeffery Frye

This is the Best Place to go for Breakfast-everytime we sail to the bay this is a must breakfast place for us. The staff is friendly and traffic moves so the wait is not long. Food is great and reasonably priced.

Larry Menser

Stopped in Pasquale’s Cafe for breakfast while docked at a nearby marina. They were crowded and we were told there would be a 10 to 15-minute wait for a table – it was really just over 5 minutes. The food was excellent as always! The service was very good throughout our visit.

Brad Cox

Had to have some decent breakfast while at Put-in-Bay Pasquale’s Cafe is the ticket. Nice menu, plenty of options from breakfast sandwiches to eggs Benedict. The coffee is decent as well. They make a nice breakfast Bloody Mary with maple bacon. Definitely recommend that on the morning after.

Melanie Bowers

On the main street. The food was excellent, the party that had just left this restaurant said, the best pizza she had ever had. The breakfast is delicious and the quantity of food is very generous. Reasonable prices for such a resort area. The property was clean and the staff attentive.

Tim Louis
Outstanding breakfast and wonderful waitress! We had breakfast here. I ordered light, fruit, a couple of sausage links, and a muffin. The muffin was hot and very flaky. The sausage was some of the best I’ve ever eaten. The fruit was fresh and delicious. Great place.
Brenda Haas

Never having been to Put-n-Bay we found this place for breakfast. It was great. We all got a great breakfast and the service was good too. The food was hot and the place was clean. It will be busy and a wait from 9-10 AM.

Shay Miller